I am sorry - somehow my "subscribe" to the forum got lost since April 30 - so I did not know about this big issue since then. I must say: From my side I am very disappointed that obviously none of the commentators did try to see what really happened! For what do I put a lot of work in generating the films - if nobody even tries to learn from them -- especially by expanding your limited knowledge about what happens around you while you are piloting! Let me take this happening as an example between FACTS and FAKES by analysing what is said and what was in the film:
http://www.emmerich-j.de/EDDF/Films/201 ... 759-82.mp4 starting at film-time 0:24:42:
fg101 wrote in Mon Apr 30, 2018 8:23 am:I was doing a short trip from EDDM to EDDF on 29th April 2018 at around 18:30 UTC and was in contact with ATCjomo. Now, I was inbound EDDF at around 60 NM out and i kept waiting for further instructions and kept asking him for further instructions and never replied.
18:39:30: fg101 reporting in just with "Hello" - not with any request or whatever
18:41:34: fg101 now reporting in with "inbound EDDF"
(on fl120 speed 351 (ATC is busy))18:42:26: fg101 reported in second time,
([i]now on fl80 at speed 325)[/i]
18:43:19: ATC -> fg101 info: rw07R
18:46:31: ATC -> fh101 "left turn 284"
(info: there are 7 active targets - all using typing - some causing problems)18:52:21: ATC -> fg101 "max speed is 250 below fl100" (he is on 318 on fl055 !!)
18:53:49 [b]fg101 starts turning right to airport - unauthorized !! Trouble starts
it does not look as if he could recover for a proper intercept 07R - so I first wanted to get him left 250 for recover - but then decided to rather let him do a short circle -- and forgot to change left/right !!
YES: That was a failure on both sides!18:54:22: ATC -> fg100 " turn left 070" He turns right!
18:55:17: ATC -> asks why he turns right?
18:55:48: ATC now clarifies: GOARROUND on 3000 hdg 070
18:55:48: fg101 "inserted 070 in the AP" + alt 3000
18:57:03: fg101 "awaiting further instructions"
(ATC wonders why - and is busy)18:59:02: fg101 again "awaiting further instructions"
(ATC wonders why - and is busy)19:02:44: fg101 again asking
(does he not see that there are lots of problems with others and I am constantly typing - but there is no problem for him??)
19:04:06: fg101 "ATC do you read?"
19:05:10: fg101 is tired to wait such a long time -- And starts cruising wild/uncontrolled - turning back to EDDF.
19:06:08: ATC is also tired of typing typing typing to someone having no problems - and neglects him
19:06:31: fg101 neglects ATC
===>> So: What do you guys suggest?
Me getting some secretaries to take over the typing (who pays for that?) ?
Or maybe customers use mumble ? (for installation/operation see http://www.emmerich-j.de/Mumble/mumble.html)
Or getting only customers who also consider the ATC-workload with customers in trouble - and not so much with him being in no trouble!
But in any case: Pls consider: The films are there for learning - yes - also for me - but especially for beginners.